It is common for people in the same industry or line of work to discuss business. Trade associations exist primarily to address challenges or problems common to the trade, but any discussion that includes the cost or pricing structure of individual businesses is a slippery slope.
A federal district court convicted an executive of a ready-mix concrete company for criminal conspiracy to restrain trade. The defendant tried to portray his communication with competitors as innocent trade talk. A federal appeals court, however, ruled that the evidence supported findings of price fixing, bid rigging, and market allocation.
The other case in this issue involved a labor union’s ability to recover from a public works payment bond. The union alleged that a subcontractor on a job had failed to pay mandatory contributions to employee benefit plans. A Massachusetts court ruled that a collective bargaining agreement created a “contractual relationship” between the prime contractor (the principal on the payment bond) and the labor union.
